Best memory and why?

The obvious choice for many will be James Tarkowski’s stoppage time equaliser in the final Merseyside derby at Goodison Park, but mine has to be that first Premier League game at our new home. The siren, Z Cars and the emergence of the players will forever give me goosebumps. A moment more than 20 years in the making that will live long in the memory.

Worst moment and why?

2025 was definitely more enjoyable than the previous few years, so a worst moment is difficult to pick. The day the doors closed at Goodison Park will probably fit into this category, but more so from an emotional perspective. Taking time to process the magnitude of the day and the moment the full-time whistle blew, was unforgettable. We were all a part of history that day. I truly believe it signified the rebirth of the club.

If I could drink a New Year’s brew with one member of our squad/management it would be…

Leighton Baines

and I’d ask him…

to sign all my Baines-themed merchandise, while featuring on the podcast of course.

The thing that’s infuriated me in 2025 is…

The expectation that has materialised about Everton being good enough to qualify for Europe this season. Sometimes realism is not appreciated, but this squad is very much at the beginning of a major rebuild. The impact of injuries, suspensions and Afcon has laid bare the fragility of the squad. There will be progress, but there have to be tempered expectations this season.

My gut tells me 2026 will bring…

More excitement and progression, especially as we head into the 2026-27 season. The summer transfer window will really see Everton start to make their move in the market. I cannot wait to see what the future will bring.

Find more from Mike Richards at Unholy Trinity